Date: Tue, 19 Dec 2006 19:16:23 -0600 (CST) From: "Randall J. Scalise" To: Emily Boyd cc: bialy harvey , David Crowe , Peter Duesberg , "Randall J. Scalise" , Fred Olness , John Cotton , Robert Park , James Randi Subject: Re: Dear "colleague" Scalise Dear "colleague" Bialy, Here is the address to which Ms. Boyd can send a copy of "Oncogenes, Aneuploidy, and AIDS: A Scientific Life and Times of Peter H. Duesberg": SMU Physics 0175 3215 Daniel Avenue Dallas, TX 75275-0175 I did read the Amazon Reviews just now. Here is my favorite: Mr. Bialy's opus. Science fiction at its worst., July 19, 2006 Reviewer: Manny Kimmel (Ohio) - See all my reviews Mr. Bialy's journeyman's prose never fails to bore. He creates a parallel universe in which the modern-day plague of AIDS is a fiction created by greedy and ambitious scientists, politicians, activists, Pharma executivies, and other assorted henchmen. Against this backdrop of evil, we are given a Christ figure, played by a scientist at a California university who would save the world from the great lie that is AIDS. Oddly, Mr. Bialy's descriptions of our hero smacks of a schoolgirl crush. Would that we had learned whether this curious realtionship was ever consummated. Mr. Bialy takes a halfway good science fiction story idea (what if HIV were harmless??) and beats it to death with excrutiating, ham-handed detail. Life is too short for this kind of drivel. Shame on me for wasting several hours of my life on this nonsense. Shame on YOU if you repeat my mistake. Have an enlightened day, --Randall J. Scalise ,____________________________________________________________________. | Office: +1(214)768-2504 | Department of Physics | | Dept: +1(214)768-2495 | 102 Fondren Science Building | | FAX: +1(214)768-4095 | 3215 Daniel Avenue | | Email: scalise@smu.edu | Southern Methodist University | | http://www.phys.psu.edu/~scalise | Dallas, TX 75275-0175 | `--------------------------------------------------------------------'